Today'sBanker
1–1HT 1–0
1 · New York Red Bulls40%
X · Draw24%
2 · New York City FC36%
Kick-off
GMT+1
Date
Sun 17 May 2026
Venue
Sports Illustrated Stadium
Ticket
B2S-1490297

New York Red Bulls vs New York City FC prediction — Under 3.5

Bet2Sure pickUnder 3.5 goalsGood · SS 64 · @1.55 · value -1%
Home40%Draw24%Away36%
xG 1.5 – 1.4

Form, last 5 left = oldest · 90-minute scores

New York Red Bulls
OverallDLLLWW1 D1 L3 · goals 8–13
Home gamesWDLLW7/15 pts · goals 11–12
New York City FC
OverallWLDWWW3 D1 L1 · goals 14–9
Away gamesDLWWW10/15 pts · goals 10–6
Our pickWon ✓
Under 3.5Under 3.5 goals
Sure Score
64
Odds
1.55
Our fair odds
1.57
Value
-1%
Score lean
2–1

A tight game likely – 2.9 xG in total. Comes in 64% of the scorelines we run. New York Red Bulls come in off a win (WWLL); New York City FC come in off a win (WDW). Fair price at 1.55.

All markets: bookmaker odds v our chance

fair odds = 100 ÷ our % · green = price above fair
MarketSelectionOddsOur %Fair oddsValue
Full-time result1 · New York Red Bulls2.2240%2.48-11%
X · Draw3.7024%4.16-11%
2 · New York City FC2.8636%2.81+2%
Double chance1X1.4064%1.55-10%
121.2276%1.32-7%
X21.6260%1.68-3%
Goals 1.5Over 1.51.1879%1.26-6%
Under 1.54.7521%4.85-2%
Goals 2.5Over 2.51.5758%1.73-9%
Under 2.52.3542%2.37-1%
Goals 3.5Over 3.52.4036%2.76-13%
Under 3.5 our pick1.5564%1.57-1%
GG / NGGG1.4861%1.65-10%
NG2.4539%2.54-4%
Half-time result1 HT2.7032%3.12-13%
X HT2.2540%2.48-9%
2 HT3.3028%3.63-9%

Odds shown are from when this page was last updated and can change. Always confirm the price with your bookmaker. 18+.

Our analysis

Ade Ola · Bet2Sure

Who is favoured

Nothing much separates them. New York Red Bulls win 40%, draw 24%, New York City FC win 36% – in a game like this, the price you get is more important than the side you pick. In the table: New York Red Bulls 10th (42 pts), New York City FC 11th (42 pts).

Current form

New York Red Bulls, last six matches: W L L L D W – two wins. Most recent: 3–2 at home to Columbus Crew. Scoring 1.8 and conceding 2.3 per game. No clean sheet in any of those games.

New York City FC have won three of their last six (W W D L W L). Most recent: 1–0 away at Charlotte. They are scoring freely – 2.3 goals a game.

Past meetings

Last time (Apr 2026): New York Red Bulls 1–3 New York City FC. Old results count for little – our pick is based mainly on current form and ratings.

Goals

Expected goals: New York Red Bulls 1.5 and New York City FC 1.4, about 2.9 in total. This one could be open – over 2.5 at 58% and GG at 61%.

Our pick (settled)

Before the game we picked Under 3.5 (Under 3.5 goals), Sure Score 64, odds about 1.55 against our fair price of 1.57. Most likely score: New York Red Bulls 2–1 New York City FC. Settled on the 90-minute score. 18+ – only stake what you can afford to lose.

Major League Soccer standings

Competition hub →
#TeamPWDLGDPts
1Nashville SC342383+4677
2Inter Miami3416126+2160
3New England Revolution3418412+858
4Chicago Fire3416711+1055
5Charlotte3415910+1554
6Philadelphia Union3414812+1450
7Columbus Crew3414515+747
8Orlando City SC3413714-1546
9FC Cincinnati34121012-846
10New York Red Bulls3412616-1442
11New York City FC34101212+442
12Toronto FC3491213-1539
13Atlanta United FC349619-1733
14DC United3471215-2233
15CF Montreal346820-3226

Same league, same day

League page

New York Red Bulls v New York City FC – questions and answers

Who did Bet2Sure favour in New York Red Bulls vs New York City FC?

Before kick-off our chances were New York Red Bulls win 40%, draw 24%, New York City FC win 36%. Any team fit win this one – stake small.

What is the Bet2Sure pick for New York Red Bulls vs New York City FC?

Our pick is Under 3.5 (Under 3.5 goals), odds about 1.55, with a Sure Score of 64. That means about 64 wins from every 100 picks like it.

How many goals did Bet2Sure expect in New York Red Bulls vs New York City FC?

We expect about 2.9 goals. Chance of over 2.5: 58%; over 1.5: 79%.

Will both teams score in New York Red Bulls vs New York City FC?

We give GG a 61% chance – both teams should find the net.

What is the likely score of New York Red Bulls vs New York City FC?

Our most likely score is New York Red Bulls 2–1 New York City FC. Correct scores rarely land, so use it as a guide, not a bet to bank on.

What time is New York Red Bulls vs New York City FC?

The match starts at 00:30 WAT on Sunday 17 May 2026 at Sports Illustrated Stadium (Major League Soccer).